Alleged Israeli Spy - Part II
By: S. Rowan Wolf, Ph.D., Uncommon Thought Journal
August 29, 2004 This work is under a fair use Creative Commons License

The higher powers better help Lawrence Franklin, as he has been tagged as "the Israeli spy." Franklin has supposedly been under investigation for months, and they have .... photos of him passing classified information ( FBI Probes Pentagon Spy Case). We now know that if there is not photographic evidence, then nothing happened - at least as far as anything connected to this administration goes.

One of the people interviewed about the alleged spying voices my skepticism:

"The whole thing makes no sense to me," said Dennis Ross, special envoy on the Arab-Israeli peace process in the first Bush administration and the Clinton presidency. "The Israelis have access to all sorts of people. They have access in Congress and in the administration. They have people who talk about these things," said Ross, now a senior fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. (Analyst Who Is Target of Probe Went to Israel)


As noted in An Israeli Spy in the Pentagon? Are You Kidding Me?, the neo-cons are thick in the Bush administration, and particularly in the Pentagon. Feith, in particular has recently been linked to the chain of destruction in the Iraq torture cases. Common Dreams takes a timely flashback to Pentagon's Feith Again at Center of Disaster from 5/20/04. The detailing of Feith's activities in that article ore interesting.

- his office was responsible for feeding the 12 year old data on Hussein and Iraq's capabilities to Cheney;

- his office pushed for Chalabi's entrance and influence in Iraq;

- Stephen Cambone works in Feith's office and was behind transferring Miller from Guantanamo to Abu Ghraib to "gitmoize" interrogations there.

Now we have Franklin, a specialist on Iran, who worked in the DIA and transferred to the Pentagon to work under Feith, who is pegged as a "spy."

Now, the policy focus is less towards Iraq and more towards Iran. I am not the only one questioning whether Iran is next on "the list" for both the US and Israel (An 'October Surprise'? Neocons have Iran in their Sights, Target Iran). Having someone in Feith's office acting as a liaison (read errand boy) does not seem at all surprising to me. Franklin seems a natural choice, not only because of his Iran specialist credentials, but he was a colonel in the Israeli Air Force Reserve. Therefore it seems likely that he has natural networks and friends who are Israeli.

It is being noised about that Franklin was not in a decision making position. He is an analyst. Whether his analyses did, or could, shape policy is a matter of how much you want to dismiss the influence of information and analysis in the decision process. While not the intent of the statement, the quote below points to the same issue:

The work done in the Pentagon's policy offices often involves regional strategic planning like deliberations on what stance the government should take in dealing with other countries. A little more than a year ago, one policy pushed from within the Pentagon would have relied on covert support for Iranian resistance groups to destabilize Iran's powerful clergy. In internal deliberations, some even raised the possibility of a military strike against an Iranian nuclear facility at Natanz. The ideas, reported in the news media at the time, came up in the context of developing a draft directive outlining the administration's overall policy toward the regime in Tehran. (F.B.I. Said to Reach Official Suspected of Passing Secrets)
.

So round and round we go. But the question begs to be asked of who started this ball rolling. Given the looming Republican Convention and the run up to the election, Bush hardly needs a "spy" on his watch - particularly one supposedly working for an ally, and not one woven into the neo-con block.

Article Links

FBI Probes Pentagon Spy Case, 8/28/04 CBS

Pentagon's Feith Again at Center of Disaster, 5/20/04, Lobe, IPS

Pentagon official investigated for leaking classified material on US policy to Israel, 8/29/04 Anderson & Silver, Independent/UK

F.B.I. Said to Reach Official Suspected of Passing Secrets, 8/29/04, Risen, NYT

Analyst Who Is Target of Probe Went to Israel, 8/29/04 Ricks & Wright, Wa. Post

An Israeli Spy in the Pentagon? Are You Kidding Me?, 8/28/04, Wolf, UTJ